Return to Ten Years of the Bulletin page  I      Home page

Transcript

TEN YEARS OF THE WW2RSG BULLETIN

Ben Brooksbank

(From Bulletin 10/3, pp. 66-70)

This article was written to celebrate the 10th Anniversary of the Group, which evolved from the response of six railway modellers to a letter in Railway Modeller from Nick Ellis in November 1989. They obtained the willing co-operation of Peter Erwood, of Arcturus Press, who kindly undertook and subsidized a fledgling Bulletin, and brought out Issue No. 1 in May/June 1990. It is clear that the first issues depended heavily on the energy and initiative of Pete Erwood, who by documenting the background and interests of several - but not all - of the early members, airing their views about the aims of the Group, establishing an Information Exchange and then encouraging the contribution of articles and notes by members about their own specialities, set the course of the Bulletin as a serious periodical.

By January 1991 there were 18 members, and in February a Committee met and drew up a formal Constitution. In the first few years the content of the Information Exchange with its questions and relatively brief answers, together with a large number of short Notes on a wide variety of subjects, made up most of the Bulletin. Few members were motivated to write full-length articles. No substantial article appeared until the first issue of 1991, when founder-member and enduring linchpin of the Group, Mike Christensen, provided the first of a series on `Wartime Emergency Connections', his subject being the works at Sandy. Soon after, John McCrickard contributed an article on the Northallerton Avoiding Line. These authors set a standard for authoritative, illustrated articles for the Bulletin that has been maintained and developed since then. Their subject was subsequently extended to Wartime Depots and Special Stations. Christensen has also described, inter alia, the Preparation of Bridges for Demolition in the event of Invasion, Protection of Railways near Airfields, Ferrying Locomotives across the Sea, and the Financial Arrangements of the Railways with the Government, and has authored the only book published (by Arcturus) under the Group's banner, The Shropshire & Montgomeryshire Light Railway under Military Control, 1941-1960.

This first 1991 issue (Bulletin No. 6, now referred to as ‘1/6’ because the first twelve issues up to March/April 1992 were called ‘Series One’) was also the first with ‘photographs’. However, the reproduction was poor because it could only be done by photocopying. Unfortunately, owing to lack of funds, this is still the case and any subsequent improvement has only been through the employment of better photocopying equipment. Christensen, McCrickard, and later other contributors, also provided drawings of professional standard, the reproduction of which has naturally not presented the same problem.

Likewise at this time, articles - usually on unfamiliar topics, from Railway Wireless Operations to Steel Shelters for Signalmen - began to flow from the accomplished pen of member Derek Winkworth (`DWW'), starting with an amusing account of the wartime transport of water from Scotland to London for mixing with whisky; DWW also contributed his own detailed account of a Wartime Connection - that at Staines. In 1993, new contributors attempting to provide articles of sound and solid information included the present Editor, Ben Brooksbank, with his account of ‘The Impact of the Air War on the ECML’.

The Bulletin began to benefit from the wide knowledge and thorough researches, in his capacity as Deputy Chief Librarian at the MoD Library, of member John Woods. His first contribution was a list of official War Office documents in the PRO relating to railways. Later, some of the products of his researches have appeared: for example, extensive lists of the locations and movements of WD locomotives (including those hired), comprehensive statistics on WD Railways, and an annotated list of ROF’s. However, as with many member's researches, space limitations preclude the publication of Woods' extensive extracts related to railways from the War Office ‘Red Books’, nor of his monumental Directory of Military Installations and MoS Factories in Britain, but copies are available to Group members at cost. Other members have contributed useful descriptions of these installations: Major S.A. Simmons produced a description, with a good map, of the great Ammunition Depot at Bramley; H.J. (‘Tiny’) Williams, starting with Huntspill in 1998, has been providing a series of thorough studies on Military Depots and ROF’s, several of which are still to appear in the Bulletin.

Also in 1993, the Chairman, Rob Bayliff, joined in by presenting his list of SR-derived ‘Mobile Workshop Trains, Ramp Wagons and Brake Vans’. The Chairman, however, had wider horizons: by contributing a list of ‘Railway Lines of Communication in France, Belgium, Netherlands and Germany’, he began the extension of the scope of the Bulletin to Overseas. Next, John Allison sent in a comprehensive list he had compiled of the RAF Bomber Command attacks on railway targets in Germany, Italy and Occupied Europe, which - regrettably - could only be cut down to a summary of a size limited by that of the Bulletin.

The coverage by the Group already included the operations of British and American military railway units in overseas theatres of war, but it now found itself engaged in a major further expansion. Firstly, there had to be an alteration of the terms of the Constitution of the Group to include the Railways of Foreign Countries, including Enemies as well as Allies in World War Two. Secondly, the content of the Bulletin had to be divided into Home and Overseas sections. These changes also coincided with some enthusiasts from overseas joining the Group. Walter Rothschild, Keith Chester, Werner Köhler and Hans Wervers from abroad have contributed a range of material about the impact of World War Two on the railways of other countries. Walter Rothschild in particular has sent enough material to the Editor to fill several issues of the Bulletin, all about the Foreign Railways whose involvement in World War Two tends to be ignored by the insular British.

Group members have had access to the records of individuals - both surviving and deceased - about railway operations during the war. In 1995, Christensen documented a series of especially interesting entries from the diaries of the late Rev. David Tipper, and more recently those of the late Graham Vincent on the S&M Light Railway, while member Richard Taylor has contributed a sample of his own wartime ‘train-spotting’ records, as has Ken Wightman (via DWW). (One day, if everything else dries up, the present Editor may do likewise with his wartime records). In addition, commencing in 1997, Williams has contributed several informative, illustrated articles about military railway installations in Britain, based on his personal experiences of working in them just after the war, the first being about Marchwood Port.

In the first Bulletin (10/1) of 2000, there have been two further ‘recollection’ papers: the remarkable experiences of Sgt. David Miller, who was an engine driver in an RE Railway Operating Company on the supply route to Burma during the war, and an account by Stephen Broughton, a fireman in wartime on the LMSR, of the vagaries of the WD and USA freight engines. The opportunity has also been taken to reproduce - with permission - from previous publications first-hand recollections of wartime railway experiences, for example ‘Berlin Express, Post-War’, an article by the late D.S. Barrie in a 1948 issue of The Locomotive.

Over the years, members have frequently sent in reviews of books of interest and relevance, and also references to topics on Railways and World War Two in articles in the principal railway periodicals. This valuable information has been listed systematically and is in the capable hands of Alan Clothier. Together with notes contributed by Group members on sources of archives and on military railway models, all this information has enabled the Bulletin to become - at least since the compilation of an Index in 1996 - quite a valuable document of reference in its own right. Meanwhile in the background, Tony Cane has been composing from the outset a comprehensive Database of Photographs and Drawings, and has kept track of relevant videos, while he and Bayliff look after a considerable collection of the photographs themselves on behalf of the Group. Copies of the Database and of the collected photographs are available to members at cost, and lists of the latter have been circulated with the Bulletin in recent years.

In 1993, after re-equipping following loss of his computer by flooding, Peter Erwood redesigned the format of the Bulletin to that broadly followed since then. However, most regrettably, he had to give up his Editorship of the Bulletin at the end of 1994, and the job passed over from a professional to an inexperienced amateur. This was reflected in the ending of his cogent and entertaining Editorials. He also contributed important articles based on his personal expertise, such as on Armoured Trains and on Copyright and Testamentary Dispositions, and more recently on Heavy Anti-Aircraft Guns on Railway Mountings. However, he had set a stamp and design on which to build, and thanks to an increasing quantity and breadth of erudite contributions it has been possible to keep going a flourishing and expanding Bulletin. Also in 1993 the Group suffered the death of its founding Chairman, Geoff Balfour; in his place, Rob Bayliff was elected.

Under the new editorship in 1995, there was no particular change in the content of the Bulletin. Rather, there was an evolution, consequent upon the receipt, from a steadily increasing group membership, of articles that covered a widening range of topics. Bayliff presented a translation from Dutch of a masterly account by Hans Wervers of the ‘Locomotives and Rolling Stock of the US Army Transportation Corps’. With a number of photographs and scale drawings, this article ran to nearly 15 pages and set a new standard of length as well as depth. In another 1995 issue, in-depth documentation of a different kind, that of wartime special trains, was initiated by Richard Taylor with a complete list of Evacuation trains on the SE Section of the SR from London in September 1939. This was followed by DWW's listing of all the troop trains to Scottish ports for Operation Avonmouth, the Norwegian Expedition in April 1940. (After those early days of the war, the blanket of secrecy became so thick that such fascinating detail was very rarely documented and so cannot be found in the PRO). Similarly, in Bulletin 8/6, Alan Blackburn had a comprehensive list of ‘SR Works Orders for Military Equipment’.

Later in 1995, the extension of the Bulletin into the railways of distant and lesser-known countries was underlined by the first of several notable contributions - here on Slovak Railways - from John Bushby. Subsequently this leading expert on Eastern Europe has provided reviews of foreign books of which few members would otherwise have ever been aware, and major articles on ‘German Anti-Aircraft Guns’, on ‘Hitler's Projected Broad-Gauge Railway’ and his ‘Wolfschanze’, on ‘War Locomotives Preserved in Eastern Europe’, and on the Polish Railways. Bulletin 6/4 (1996) contained an article, ‘Austrian Railways in World War Two’, the first of Walter Rothschild's well-grounded and discerning articles and book reviews that have taken members deeply into the railways of Central and Eastern Europe. Several of Rothschild's shorter pieces have appeared subsequently, and in 1999-2000 some of his longer features have embraced material translated from German about Recollections from North Africa, the alleged Train-Busting in Germany by Allied Airmen, and ‘Der Reichsbahn hinter den Ostfront’.

The last issue of 1996 featured the first article, ‘Resurrection of the Belgian Railways in 1944-45’, of an excellent series on the impact of the war on overseas railways by Walter Dendy - a member of the Group able to write from first-hand experience. He has subsequently described the restoration of the Netherlands and French Railways, and his contributions have also included features on ‘Stalin's Special (broad-gauge) Train to the Potsdam Conference’ - a topic later enlarged upon by John Bushby and by Keith Chester, on ‘Wehrmacht Leave Trains’, on ‘Russian Locomotives Abandoned in Iran’, and on ‘Australian Railways’. In Bulletin 8/1 Philip Pacey had written a good article, based on an earlier one in French, on the narrow-gauge ‘Reseau des Bains de Mer’, and Dendy has since written on ‘The Narrow-Gauge Railways in Normandy’.

Important contributions on overseas railways have been made by Werner Köhler, including a listing of ‘BAOR Trains in Germany in 1950’, and translations of articles from Lok Magazin on the German extension of the Western Desert Railway and on German military diesel locomotives. In the past year or so, the locomotives working in Germany at the end of the war have been discussed at length, in articles reproduced with permission from other periodicals, both indigenous German stocks (Bulletin 9/2) and stocks commandeered from Occupied Countries (Bulletin 10/2).

Outstanding contributions to the Bulletin describing the repair of war-ravaged railways have been those of member Maj.-Gen. Bertie Parsons. In Italy in 1944-45, he was there - actually directing operations, and he has allowed the copying of major sections of the official and highly professional account of the ‘Restoration of the Italian Railways’ written by him for the Royal Engineers. A valuable article published in the Railway Gazette in 1945 about ‘French Railway Resistance and Reconstruction’ was reproduced - with permission - in issue 8/1, and currently Dendy is providing an interesting account of the ‘SNCF in the War’, based on articles published years ago in La Vie du Rail. Parsons has also written an account of his earlier work - constructing railway facilities in Kent for the super-heavy guns and in assisting with the repair of bomb damage in London. Related to the last, Brooksbank has produced some examples of his documentation of War Damage on British Railways, and DWW has provided reports detailing damage on the SR.

From the outset, attempts have been made from time to time to focus on particular topics. Favoured topics have been: USATC 0-6-0T’s, German ‘Krieglok’s’, WD 2-10-0’s, and transportation of AFV’s. Thus in Issue 6/1, again 15 pages were devoted to one article - an authoritative account by Christensen in detail and accompanied by striking photographs, of the ‘Use of Special Warflat Trains’, and in Issue 7/6 Woods added a lot more information. Unfamiliar facts about the post-war fate of USA 0-6-0T’s were described by David Notarius, later by others and accompanied by rare photographs. The subject of ‘Kriegslok’s’ was dealt with first in an article by the Group Secretary, Greg Martin, and followed up by Tony Lambert. Lambert is a member whose expert knowledge of matters European derives from personal experience as a RE(Tn) officer during the war. He has contributed many notes on a variety of subjects, and his longer pieces have included the Melbourne Military Railway and WD 0-6-0T’s surviving from World War One. The curious topic of Aircraft Crashes on Railway Lines - a surprisingly frequent occurrence - has been documented at some length by Brooksbank, by DWW and by Cyril Rushworth. Another topic has been Ambulance Trains, with interesting papers by Alan Turley, Richard Strange and others. A recurring topic in Information Exchange has been Railway Guns, and this subject has been tackled in depth by Erwood, Bushby, and Iain Pardoe. Another is Military Rolling Stock, about which noteworthy illustrated descriptions and inventories have been made by George Moon, Brian Hardy, and Rob Bayliff. Armoured trains are a popular subject, and for Bulletin 8/1 permission was fortunately obtained to reproduce from SA Rail & Harbours an illustrated account of a unique armoured locomotive employed in South Africa. Naturally, the Longmoor Military Railway has often cropped up, and Williams and Simmons have written at some length on the topic.

Topics introduced as Queries in the Information Exchange have spawned new areas of research, resulting in noteworthy copy for the Bulletin. A case in point arose from a Query placed by member Robin Wilson, who sent for interpretation the copy of a sample sheet from a document found at the Museum of Army Transport (MAT), Beverley. It showed coded secret Schedules of Military Special Trains, and was promptly explained (in part) by Gerald Jacobs, another member with first-hand experience of railway work going back to the war period. He himself not only possesses a large book of these Schedules, but also four priceless hand-written record books dating from May 1944 until well after the war. These were kept by assistants attending the Conferences held two or more times a day at the War Office, where senior railway officials met with officers of the British and US Armies to arrange the despatch of Supply trains, principally for Operation Overlord, running under the special Schedules from depots to ports for shipment to NW Europe. A sample page of these records, together with a listing of the secret codes used for Depots and Ports was reproduced in Bulletin 7/6. The books themselves have now been photocopied for ‘Posterity’ - but a volunteer is still needed to write up the whole story.

In the longer Bulletins of the last five years, many facsimiles of interesting documents from the archives of the PRO, NRM and other sources have been featured, notably those trawled by DWW from the British Railways Board Records repository in Bayswater, and by Brooksbank from the PRO. If possible, trouble has been taken to maintain an appearance of authenticity by retyping them in their original font and format. The first important one was given by the Librarian at the NRM, who has greatly helped the Group by having the Bulletin exhibited in the Museum Library, as has his counterparts at the IWM and the MAT. This facsimile, with scale drawings, was on the subject of ‘Special Wagons for Very Large Naval Guns’. Subsequent facsimiles concerned such as the following: Measures planned (or carried out) under the Threat of Invasion in 1940, Instructions on the Handling of Ammunition Trains, Preparations for Overlord, Reports on the Air Raid on York in April 1942, the Fate of Railway Staff in Paris and in the Channel Islands at the Fall of France, a list of those curious Wagon Names used by the GWR, and so on...

In the Modelling Section of the Bulletin, apart from the periodic updates of information about military railway models, particular features have been descriptions and illustrations by founding member Tony Cane, including those of his own brilliant models, by Philip Parker, by Werner Köhler, Mike Walshaw, Mike Webber, and Lieut.-Col. Paul Malmassari, and most recently a very detailed piece by George Moon.

Return to Ten Years of the Bulletin page  I      Home page

--------------------